People en Español marked its 50 Most Beautiful issue Monday night with a glitzy celebration of the stars. Ricky Martin presented legendary West Side Story actress Rita Moreno with a Lifetime Achievement Award at the magazine’s annual Los 50 Más Bellos event. Moreno, 82, is one of 12 members of the EGOT (Emmy, Grammy, Oscar, and Tony) club. Actress Génesis Rodríguez, Emilio Estefan, and Miss Universe María Gabriela Isler also attended the festivities, which took place at Capitale in New York City.

The magazine unveiled the annual 50 Más Bellos issue earlier this month. Martin and Rodriquez, as well as Modern Family’s Sofia Vergara and Jennifer Lopez were among those selected as this year’s “most beautiful.”

See photos of celebrities at this week’s hottest parties in our gallery!