Remember those girls in high school who were good at everything? School, sports, ceramics class — you name it, they excelled at it. And remember how you secretly wanted to be just like them? They set an example for others to follow, whether they intended to or not. That’s kind of how we feel about the nominees in the Social Media Awards All-Around Superstar category. Pictured, clockwise from top left, are Aimee Song of Song of Style, Erica Schuman of Cupcakes and Cashmere, and a snap from the Instagram of Erica Chan Coffman and Lauren Kolodny, the women behind Honestly WTF. They — along with Joy Cho of Oh Joy! and Kimberly Pesch of Eat.Sleep.Wear. — had such great tweets, pins, Instas and more, that we couldn’t just nominate them in one category of our first-ever Social Media Awards! Which is why we need you to vote for your all-around favorite. Check out the nominees now (including links to all of their fabulous feeds) and cast your vote by this Sunday, September 15 at 11:59 p.m. ET, when polls close. Be sure to share your pick on social media using hashtag #InStyleSMAs, and don’t be shy — all the cool kids are doing it!