Bet you didn’t know: We design two separate covers each month, one for newsstands and retail locations and one for our subscribers. Between the September coverline-packed newsstand edition (above, left) and the streamlined subscriber’s cover (above, right), we don’t know which one we like better! (Having a fabulously fun and versatile subject like Drew Barrymore makes it all the more difficult to choose…) Help us decide by voting for your favorite below.

MORE:
We Asked, You Tweeted: See Readers Pose With Drew Barrymore’s InStyle Cover!
Listen to the Music from Drew Barrymore’s September Cover Shoot
In Case You Missed It: Our Amazing Twitterview with Drew Barrymore (and Special Guest Star Jimmy Fallon)