Don't Miss:

It is tied between fresh homemade peach ice cream and pistachio ice cream.

Love Mint chocolate chip.

I LOVE Strawberry Cheescake Ice cream on a hot summer day like today! Just got some at the store in fact!!

Mine is a toss up between Cookies and Cream and Chocolate chip cookie dough. Although I love the Breyer’s specialty flavored ice cream Smores. Yummo!

Hands down my favorite is coffee icecream – Haagen Daaz is best cause you can’t get Howard Johnson’s anymore.

~ My favorite ice cream flavor is Mocha Chocolate Chip ~ Starbucks is quite good !

My favorite flavor is Strawberry Cheesecake!! Yummy!

BLACK RASPBERRY

Love them all! Favorite is Raspberry Chip.

Blueberry Pie!! The-Best-Flavor-Ever!! Graeters is a must stop when we visit my brother in Cinci!!

My husband and I LOVE the Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip from Graeters! We love the store so much, that when I convinced him to move from Ohio (home of Graeters) to Kentucky, his only stipulation was that the town must have Graeters Ice Cream…so, Lexington it is!

Since I’ve moved out of state, I either have to buy what is stocked at Kroger or order online…so worth every cent! There is nothing better in the world…I’ve turned so many Michigan folks onto Graeters, they won’t eat anything else now. My all-time fave flavor? Black Raspberry Chip, or in the fall, Pumpkin Pie is like a slice of love in a cone!!

When I was younger everyone use to say I was a “chip off the old block”–and when your young you don’t get it. So, every time we went to Graeter’s which was a special occasion, I got something with chips in it. I still do to this day, I love all flavors with chips in them. I might be a geek for doing it, as I am told by my nieces, but at least I am unique and have tried them all…

Loooove Black Raspberry Chip!!!!! But Pumpkin Pie is my all-time, though sadly seasonal.

Love Black Raspberry chip, though Pumpkin Pie is my all-time favorite, though sadly seasonal.

Grew up with Graeter’s and it is still my favorite ice cream even though I no longer live in the original distribution area. My favorites………..mint chocolate chip, black raspberry chip, and a new favorite, COCONUT! YUM!

I like chocolate chip cookies and mint ice cream! I love greaters a lot!!!!!!
It is one of the best in town!

My friends and I walked home past the Graeters in College Hill in the 60′s. More often that not, we stopped for a treat most days! Yummmmmmmm. Still my fav ice cream today! Black raspberry chip.

I love them all but my favorite is black rasoberry chip!

So love the minut chocolate chip! Always stop there when in Cincinnati!

My favorite is bourbon ball ice cream with butter pecan and mint chocolate chip coming in a close tie for second.

Although I love all of the flavors, I’d have to go with the Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip.

somebody had given me a free coupon for a pint of this ice cream,I had bought rhe red rasberry chip,and let me tell you that that is the best ice cream I had ever eaten,It was so delishes,I dont even put it in a bowl,right out of the container…so so good….hope i win this,iit would make me so happy…..

I love Butter Pecan!!! The nuts are just right!!! Flavor, flavor, flavor!!!!

Love love love The Graeter’s Strawberry Chip!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

My old fave was Dutch Chocolate Almond, but they don’t make it anymore. New fave is Buckeye Blitz.

Greaters Black Raspberry Chip is the ultimate summertime treat – ok all year long but especially in the hot summer! We smash it between 2 chocolate cookies to make the best anytime treat!

Mint Chocolate Chip

Humphry Slocombe’s Secret Breakfast (Bourbon + Corn Flakes), sounds soo wrong but tastes soo good

Graeters is by far the best .Even the vanilla is superior to other brands.You can tell good ice cream by it’s weight and density.Graeters knows how to make a good quality ice cream and it shows by there celebrity endorsements.

Greetings Graters from a Navy Sailor in Rhode Island…currently serving my last tour, originally from Cincinnati, have almost (18) years in the Navy, having traveled (26) countries/I still have YET to find anything that replaces the AMAZING taste of Graeters Ice Cream, I have shipped your ice cream to many of my friends over the years for gifts & I’m always telling people they have to try it. I lived in WA state for (4) straight years & glad to see it’s finally being sold in stores there (after I left). I have been stationed overseas for the last three years, coming back to the states, I went to visit my cousin in NJ (originally from Cincinnati) recently & she even had it in the stores there, we got some & shared it together! I couldn’t get it overseas the last three years or now even stateside in RI, unless I ship it! It would be awesome for a taste of home to arrive on my doorstep, as a kid I would have said “Mint Chocolate Chip,” as an adult, I say my favorite – is Raspberry Chip!

my favorite flavor of graeters is vanilla chocolate chip

I SPENT THE SUMMER IN dillondale and almost every evening we would drive to Kenwood and have a dish of youre ice cream . Now back home in Mass. we had friends send some out to us in a hot ice box We trully miss it ..We sure did enjoy having it sent to us /Hopefully we will be back for more of Graeters yummy ice cream. Ilike all the flavors

Not having tried them all (hope to remedy that), my fave is coconut chocolate chip, which I’ve turned SEVERAL friends onto this summer!

Graeter’s Peach is by far and away my favorite and its really hard to get in DC. Pick me, pick me!! That stuff tastes like heaven in a bowl!

i love them all but my favorite is raspberry .”

While visiting Cincy in July I stopped at Graeters in Hyde Park to pick u[p my 8 pack-3 black raspberry chip,, peach, 2 choclate chip, mocha chip, and mint chip to bring back to Fairfax, VA. . While I waited I ordered 2 scoops of Banana Chocolate Chip….I want to marry it!! Unfortunately it is seasonal and I won’t be back to Cincy until October. I guess I will have to be content with the pumpkin pie. It is all good!

Butter Pecan and well, I just love ice cream!

Black raspberry, cherry choc chip, and mint choc chip!!

Hey guys, i think you are supposed to put your comments in on InStyle’s Facebook fans only page. click on: Facebook.com/instyle

Hit like unless you are already a fan.

I was introduced to Graeter’s here in South Carolina at our local Kroger’s and it is awesome. I do love the Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip the best! Num!

Love the black raspberry chocolate chip. had a cone a couple of weeks ago from the graeters on fountain square. perfect break to the day.

Our favorite is Black Raspberry Chip!!!!! My Hubby likes Butter pecan. Mint Chocolate chip is also a winner also a winner. When we moved to Florida we use to tell people about Graeters Ice Cream and what they were missing out on. There is no comparison. Thank goodness we can find it in Jacksonville now

Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip. The best of fruity berry taste and chocolate!

I love Graeter’s Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip!!!! Lived in Cincy for a few years and it’s easy to appreciate the best when it’s made in your backyard! I even had the opportunity to pour the chocolate into the French Pot and watch the whole process of how they make ice cream. It’s amazing and SO good! Wish they made it in northern Ohio. Send me some cause my Graeter’s magnet on my fridge is lonely!

I love Coconut Chip

Since my time at University of Cincinnati 25+ years ago (yes, Graeter’s on Ludlow is the old hang-out), my standard go-to has always been the double chocolate chip — there’s never really any question though I have totally enjoyed the seasonal hazelnut chip as well as the Buckeye Blitz (chocolate + peanut butter = happy mouth).