Nina Dobrev, The Vampire Diaries
Frank Ockenfels/The CW; The CW/Quantrell (2)

When we caught up with Nina Dobrev at New York Fashion Week, she set the romance score for her character Elena on The Vampire Diaries! Given the choice to “take” the heart of one of the show’s many men and “stake” another, she said: “I would stake Klaus (Joseph Morgan), but as Elena, I would take Matt (Zach Roerig) because he was in love with her and she loved him.” And she wasn’t the only one with an opinion! You sunk your teeth into the question, too, and now it’s finally time to reveal the Mystic man who stole the most hearts! Find out your top picks in the gallery!