Carrie DiariesJordan Strauss/WireImage; LANDOV; INF

Now that The CW announced it will transform Candace Bushnell’s The Carrie Diaries young adult novel into a TV show, we have to wonder: Who will play a younger Carrie and Samantha? (FYI: Charlotte and Miranda aren’t in the book.) While we wait to find out, we asked a few celebrities to play casting director and pick their favorite budding stars for the small-screen series. See all the celebrity picks in the gallery, and tell us your choices in the comments!

MORE:TV’s Most Fashionable Shows Ever