Chelsea and MarkGetty Images

Chelsea Kane and Mark Ballas shot to the top of the Dancing With the Stars leaderboard last night! The pair took a non-traditional route to dance the Viennese waltz to the Harry Potter song “Hedwig’s Theme,” and they definitely got into the magical spirit—Ballas wore a wizard’s cap, while Kane’s dress looked witch-inspired. “I figured once I started gluing rhinestones to my face in the makeup room this morning, that might come up,” Kane said of their deviation from the norm, which scored them 26 points from the judges. “But we were really careful this dance about getting all those technical moves in. We had a blast. We were dancing to Harry Potter, we had to go to this theme.” Click through to see the rest of the looks from last night’s Dancing With the Stars classical theme week.

MORE: Dancing With the Stars Style News!