Pia ToscanoCourtesy of Fox Flash

Pia Toscano got voted off American Idol last night in one of the most shocking elimination rounds in Idol history! (Who can forget Jennifer Hudson, though?) The 22-year-old New York native was widely believed to be one of the front-runners of the competition. “When she sings, she’s a bird,” judge Steven Tyler said in shock last night after host Ryan Seacrest called her name. “You’re one of the best singers in this,” said judge Randy Jackson. Her elimination also brought our favorite judge Jennifer Lopez to tears: “I’m shocked, I’m angry,” Lopez said while choking up. And not only will we miss her lovely voice, we’ll also miss her style. Click through to take a look back at Pia Toscano’s style moments. Tell us what you thought of Pia’s run on American Idol in the comments!

MORE: All American Idol Style News!